Our Products

Mermaid Water

Made from the clearest purified water from the Montauk Distilling Co., it is mixed with our MODICO vodka to give it that extra 5% ABV tail flip you’d expect from a hard seltzer. After that, we infuse it with fruits and local botanicals to make the most pure and desirable tasting water on the market. How desirable? Just ask the mermaids.

71st Regiment Gin

71st Regiment is made with 17 select botanicals all locally sourced in New York State. Our process uses both maceration and gin basket techniques to bring out classical juniper notes while also highlighting softer, more subtle notes such as honey suckle and rose petal, lavender and peppercorn. The result is an exceptionally crafted gin with a full array of botanical notes.  


It all started with our premier spirit, Black Sail Rum. Hand crafted and small batch distilled in traditional pot stills with black strap molasses, it is then matured for four years in traditional oak barrels. Black Sail is a full bodied aged rum with a first-class flavor profile. It can be sipped neat or on the rocks, and will shine in any classic rum cocktail. 

Modico Vodka

Montauk Distilling Co. is proud to introduce this premium line of vodkas to our spirit family, MODICO Vodka. MODICO is distilled from corn mashes sourced in New York State. The entire MODICO lineup is available at The Distillery in Riverhead for purchase.

Bellamy Spiced Rum

The latest of our specialty rums, Bellamy, is our spiced rum that is full of big flavors.  Expertly crafted, Bellamy showcases a complex blend of vanilla bean, allspice, citrus and other natural ingredients. The nose carries a sweet vanilla scent which carries through to a very mellow first sip followed closely by a spiced and citrusy goodness to keep it lively. Bellamy can be sipped on its own or mixed into one of your own favorite cocktails.

Awarded “Double Gold” status at the 2020 SIP Awards.

Tunney Bourbon Whiskey

Introducing Thomas J. Tunney, our Reserve bourbon whiskey made from Long Island Corn in a Copper Pot Still. This whiskey is inspired by Inspector Thomas J. Tunney who joined the New York City Police Dept in 1897. Tunney is proudly displayed on this bottle. We honor him and his service to our country and our city by naming our first whiskey after him.

Tunney Apple Redcap Bourbon Whiskey

Introducing Polly L. TUNNEY APPLE REDCAP, a smooth bourbon whiskey flavored with real apple juice, and the latest addition to our TUNNEY product line. This whiskey is named after Polly L. Tunney, a Carnegie Steel heiress who had a secret romance with, and married, Gene Tunney an American world heavyweight boxing champion. This is a smooth, flavorful bourbon with a subtle sweetness that will keep you coming back for more.

Sunburn Rum

The first of our specialty rums, Sunburn is inspired by the warm afterglow of a Montauk Sunset and a day well spent.  We take our hand crafted, pot distilled rum and infuse it with the wonderfully smooth , bold flavor of cinnamon.  Sunburn will warm you up from the inside out, leaving a touch of heat and the delightful taste of cinnamon on your tongue. Sunburn can be sipped neat or on the rocks and also works wonders in many cocktails as well as classic drinks like root beer and hot apple cider.